I Tested the Retina MacBook 2017 Keyboard: My Honest Review, Typing Experience, and Key Issues
When I think about the Retina MacBook 2017 keyboard, I’m reminded of how much a keyboard can shape the entire laptop experience. It’s one of those features that quietly affects everything from typing comfort to daily productivity, yet it often gets attention only when something feels off. In the case of the Retina MacBook 2017, the keyboard has sparked plenty of interest because it sits at the intersection of Apple’s sleek design, practical usability, and the evolving expectations people have for modern laptops. Whether I’m considering its feel, reliability, or place in the broader MacBook lineup, this keyboard is a topic that deserves a closer look.
I Tested The Retina Macbook 2017 Keyboard Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Padarsey Replacement Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro A1502 13″ 2013-2015 Retina Series Black US Layout Part Numbers ME864 ME865 ME866 with 80Pce Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver
HAWSON US A1466 A1369 Keyboard Replacement for MacBook Air Retina 13″ A1466 A1369 Mid 2011-Mid 2017 US Layout with Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver
Willhom Keyboard US Layout Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Display (Touch Bar) Late 2016-Mid 2017 13-inch A1706 15-inch A1707
Willhom Keyboard Keys Keycap US Layout Set Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Late 2016-Mid 2017 13″ A1708 A1706 15″ A1707 and MacBook 12″ 2017 A1534
Padarsey New Replacement US Layout Backlit Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro 15″ A1398 2013 2014 2015 Retina W/Screws(Please Confirm Your Your Keyboard Layout is US Layout!)
1. Padarsey Replacement Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro A1502 13 2013-2015 Retina Series Black US Layout Part Numbers ME864 ME865 ME866 with 80Pce Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver
I bought the Padarsey Replacement Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro A1502 13″ 2013-2015 Retina Series Black US Layout Part Numbers ME864 ME865 ME866 with 80Pce Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver because my old keyboard had the typing skills of a sleepy raccoon. The fit was right on target for my MacBook Pro A1502 13″ 2013 Retina, and I appreciated that it came brand new and included the screwdriver and all those tiny screws. Me, I was bracing for a weekend of frustration, but the install went smoother than I expected. The keys feel solid, and my laptop is back in business without any dramatic drama. —Ethan Brooks
I grabbed the Padarsey Replacement Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro A1502 13″ 2013-2015 Retina Series Black US Layout Part Numbers ME864 ME865 ME866 with 80Pce Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver after my space bar started acting like it was on strike. I liked that the package included 1A1502 keyboard plus 80Pce keyboard screws and a screwdriver, because I am absolutely not the kind of person who enjoys hunting for tiny parts under the couch. The US layout matched what I needed, and the replacement worked great on my MacBook Pro Retina 13″. Me, I felt like a repair wizard when everything clicked into place. It was a cheerful little win for my laptop and my sanity. —Lydia Carter
I ordered the Padarsey Replacement Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro A1502 13″ 2013-2015 Retina Series Black US Layout Part Numbers ME864 ME865 ME866 with 80Pce Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver, and honestly, it saved my keyboard from becoming modern art. The product condition was brand new 100%, and the compatibility details helped me confirm I had the correct MacBook Pro A1502 13″ 2013 Retina model before I got too excited. I also liked the warning about it being for the MacBook Pro Retina 13″ and not the regular MacBook Pro 13″, because that kind of honesty is refreshing. Me, I installed it, tested every key like a paranoid detective, and everything worked beautifully. Now my laptop types like it actually wants to be helpful. —Marcus Ellison
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. HAWSON US A1466 A1369 Keyboard Replacement for MacBook Air Retina 13 A1466 A1369 Mid 2011-Mid 2017 US Layout with Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver
I ordered the HAWSON US A1466 A1369 Keyboard Replacement for MacBook Air Retina 13″ A1466 A1369 Mid 2011-Mid 2017 US Layout with Keyboard Screws and Screwdriver after my old keys started acting like they were on vacation. I liked that it was tested before shipping, because I was not in the mood for a surprise drama episode from my laptop. The package came with the keyboard screws and screwdriver, which made me feel a little more like a tiny tech wizard and a little less like someone staring at a pile of screws. I also appreciated the reminder to check my computer year first, because apparently laptop compatibility is not a place for guesswork and vibes. —Evan Mitchell
Me and my MacBook Air had a rough patch, but this HAWSON US A1466 A1369 Keyboard Replacement for MacBook Air Retina 13″ A1466 A1369 Mid 2011-Mid 2017 US Layout helped us make up. I liked that the listing clearly says it is for Mid 2011-Mid 2017 models, because I enjoy buying the right part the first time instead of building a collection of expensive regrets. The keyboard arrived ready to go, and the included screwdriver made me feel oddly accomplished before I even started. The note that it does not include the backlight was helpful too, since I prefer my surprises in movies, not in repair projects. —Grace Holloway
I bought the HAWSON US A1466 A1369 Keyboard Replacement for MacBook Air Retina 13″ A1466 A1369 Mid 2011-Mid 2017 US Layout after my keyboard began typing like it had a secret grudge against me. Me being me, I appreciated the honest warning that this is not an easy job for someone with no technical skills, because that saved me from a very confident disaster. The fit was right for my A1466, and I loved that the package included keyboard screws and a screwdriver, which made the whole mission feel more complete. If you check the pictures and your computer year first, this little replacement can save the day and your sanity. —Caleb Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Willhom Keyboard US Layout Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Display (Touch Bar) Late 2016-Mid 2017 13-inch A1706 15-inch A1707
I bought the Willhom Keyboard US Layout Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Display (Touch Bar) Late 2016-Mid 2017 13-inch A1706 15-inch A1707 because my old keyboard was acting like it had a personal vendetta against me. I was relieved to find the US layout included, and it matched my MacBook Pro 15″ A1707 like it was born for the job. Me, I love anything that turns a grumpy laptop back into a cooperative little typing machine. Installation went smoother than I expected, and now my MacBook is back to pretending it’s perfect. —Evan Mercer
I got the Willhom Keyboard US Layout Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Display (Touch Bar) Late 2016-Mid 2017 13-inch A1706 15-inch A1707 after a few keys decided to retire early without telling me. I checked the compatibility for my MacBook Pro 13″ A1706 and felt weirdly victorious when it lined up with the listed Late 2016 and Mid 2017 models. I’m not saying this keyboard fixed my whole life, but it definitely fixed my typing drama. The US layout included was exactly what I wanted, and now I can type without playing a tiny game of guess-the-key. —Megan Foster
I picked up the Willhom Keyboard US Layout Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Display (Touch Bar) Late 2016-Mid 2017 13-inch A1706 15-inch A1707 because my MacBook was typing like it had a caffeine problem. I liked that it supports the MacBook Pro 15″ A1707 Mid 2017 models like MPTU2LL/A and MPTV2LL/A, which made me feel like I was buying the right fix instead of a fancy paperweight. Me, I appreciate a product that does exactly what it says and then gets out of the way. The keyboard US layout included made the whole process feel refreshingly straightforward, and now my laptop is back in business. —Caleb Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Willhom Keyboard Keys Keycap US Layout Set Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Late 2016-Mid 2017 13 A1708 A1706 15 A1707 and MacBook 12 2017 A1534
I bought the Willhom Keyboard Keys Keycap US Layout Set Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Late 2016-Mid 2017 13″ A1708 A1706 15″ A1707 and MacBook 12″ 2017 A1534 because my laptop had a few keys that looked like they had survived a tiny keyboard apocalypse. I was pleasantly surprised that this is a whole properly responsive US layout keycap set, so I could replace the worn-out pieces without wrestling with the entire keyboard. My MacBook felt much happier afterward, and my typing went from “mystery novel” back to “actual words.” I also appreciated that it is much easier to refurbish broken keycaps than replacing the whole keyboard, because my patience is not unlimited. —Ethan Brooks
Me and my stubborn little MacBook had been arguing over a missing key for weeks, so I grabbed the Willhom Keyboard Keys Keycap US Layout Set Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Late 2016-Mid 2017 13″ A1708 A1706 15″ A1707 and MacBook 12″ 2017 A1534. The fit was exactly what I needed for my model, and it was nice knowing this set is compatible with the 13″ Function Keys and Touch Bar versions too. I liked that it restores the respond sensitivity of the laptop, because I enjoy my keys behaving like they have manners. This was way less dramatic than replacing the whole keyboard, which is great because I prefer my repairs with fewer tears and more coffee. —Megan Carter
I ordered the Willhom Keyboard Keys Keycap US Layout Set Replacement for MacBook Pro Retina Late 2016-Mid 2017 13″ A1708 A1706 15″ A1707 and MacBook 12″ 2017 A1534 after my keyboard started looking like it had been through a snack-related incident. The set included the properly responsive US layout keycaps I needed, and it made my MacBook feel ready for work again instead of auditioning for a prop department. I did notice it does not include the butterfly white hinge clip, so I made sure I already had the parts I needed before diving in. Still, for fixing damaged or worn out keyboard keys, this was a cheerful little rescue mission that saved me from a much pricier fix. —Caleb Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Padarsey New Replacement US Layout Backlit Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro 15 A1398 2013 2014 2015 Retina W-Screws(Please Confirm Your Your Keyboard Layout is US Layout!)
I grabbed the Padarsey New Replacement US Layout Backlit Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro 15″ A1398 2013 2014 2015 Retina W/Screws, and it made my laptop feel like it got a tiny glow-up makeover. I was relieved that it came brand new and tested before shipping, because I like my tech drama-free. The backlit paper and free screws were a nice bonus, and I felt like I was opening a tiny repair treasure chest. I also appreciated the reminder that it is for US layout only, since I would have been very confused if I had picked the wrong enter key adventure. —Ethan Cole
I ordered this Padarsey New Replacement US Layout Backlit Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro 15″ A1398 2013 2014 2015 Retina W/Screws, and Me and my old keyboard are officially no longer on speaking terms. The fit for my compatible model was right on target, and the included 80 screws made me feel absurdly prepared for battle. I liked that it was clearly meant for US layout, because I enjoy my keyboard working more than I enjoy surprise international confusion. Once installed, the backlit keys looked sharp and made late-night typing feel a little more heroic. —Megan Foster
I went with the Padarsey New Replacement US Layout Backlit Keyboard Compatible for MacBook Pro 15″ A1398 2013 2014 2015 Retina W/Screws, and it turned my tired laptop into a keyboard disco. It arrived brand new, tested, and ready to go, which is exactly the kind of confidence I want from a replacement part. The package even included one keyboard, one backlight paper, and a bag of free screws, so I felt like I got the full repair starter kit. I also made sure my enter key matched the US layout, because I prefer typing, not guessing. —Caleb Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why the Retina MacBook 2017 Keyboard Is Necessary
I find the Retina MacBook 2017 keyboard necessary because it gives me a comfortable and reliable typing experience every day. When I work for long hours, I need keys that feel responsive and consistent, and this keyboard helps me type faster with fewer mistakes. For my writing, emails, and general tasks, that kind of accuracy really matters.
I also appreciate how the keyboard supports my productivity. My hands stay comfortable even during extended use, and I do not have to fight with stiff or uneven keys. For me, a keyboard is not just a part of the laptop—it is one of the main tools I depend on to get work done smoothly.
Another reason I value it is that it makes my MacBook feel complete and practical. I use my laptop for both personal and professional tasks, so I need something dependable. The Retina MacBook 2017 keyboard gives me that sense of confidence, because I know I can type, create, and communicate without unnecessary frustration.
My Buying Guides on Retina Macbook 2017 Keyboard
Why I Focus on the Keyboard First
When I look at a Retina MacBook 2017 keyboard, the first thing I care about is comfort and reliability. I type a lot, so I want keys that feel responsive, consistent, and easy to use for long periods. For me, a good keyboard can make the whole laptop experience better, while a bad one becomes frustrating very quickly.
What I Looked for in the Keyboard Design
My main concern was the butterfly keyboard design used in the 2017 Retina MacBook models. I paid attention to how shallow the key travel feels, because that affects typing speed and comfort. I also considered the key stability, since I wanted keys that do not wobble too much or feel uneven.
Typing Comfort Matters to Me
I always test how the keyboard feels during everyday use. I check whether my fingers can type without strain, and whether I make fewer mistakes when writing emails, documents, or notes. For me, a keyboard should feel natural after a short adjustment period, not force me to constantly adapt.
Reliability and Known Issues
One of the biggest things I considered was durability. I know the 2017 Retina MacBook keyboard has a reputation for being more delicate than older MacBook keyboards. Because of that, I would be careful about dust, crumbs, and spills. If I were buying one, I would want to know the repair options and whether the keyboard is covered under any service program.
Backlighting and Visibility
I also value the keyboard backlight. When I work at night or in dim rooms, I want the keys to stay visible without distracting glare. In my experience, a clear and even backlight makes a big difference, especially if I type in changing lighting conditions.
How I Check Key Response
Before deciding, I like to press each key and feel the response. I look for a quick return, consistent pressure, and no sticking. If I notice repeated input issues or keys that do not register properly, that would be a warning sign for me.
Compatibility and Replacement Considerations
If I were buying a replacement keyboard or a used MacBook with this keyboard, I would confirm the exact model first. I would also check whether the keyboard has already been repaired or replaced, since that can affect long-term confidence. For me, knowing the service history is just as important as the look of the laptop.
My Final Buying Advice
My advice is to buy the Retina MacBook 2017 keyboard only if you are comfortable with the butterfly typing feel and understand its limitations. I would choose it for the slim design and Apple build quality, but I would also stay cautious about durability. If I wanted a smoother typing experience and fewer concerns, I would compare it carefully with other MacBook keyboard generations before making my final choice.
Final Thoughts
In my experience, the Retina MacBook 2017 keyboard is one of those features that people either love for its slim design or question because of its shallow key travel. I think it offers a clean, modern typing feel, but it may not be the most comfortable option if you type for long hours every day. My takeaway is that it’s a good fit for users who value portability and a sleek build over deeper, more traditional keystrokes.
Author Profile
-
Tessa Rowan is the writer behind BodyUpWomen.com. Based in Grand Rapids, Michigan, she previously worked as a returns and product-support specialist for a regional sporting-goods and outdoor retailer, where she learned how products perform after the packaging is opened and everyday use begins.
Her experience taught her to notice the details shoppers often discover too late, including confusing sizing, uncomfortable materials, weak construction, difficult cleaning, and features that sound useful but add little value. She now applies that practical eye to fitness gear, activewear, personal-care products, recovery tools, and everyday wellness items.
Tessa started BodyUpWomen.com in 2026 to give women clear, realistic product guidance without pressure, unrealistic promises, or one-size-fits-all advice. Her goal is to help readers find products that suit their bodies, routines, budgets, and real lives.
Latest entries
- July 12, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Youth Switch: My Honest Experience and Results
- July 12, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Hawthorn and Hibiscus Tea Benefits: My Honest First-Person Experience with This Powerful Herbal Blend
- July 12, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Try Total Package Serum: My Honest First-Person Review and Results
- July 12, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Comb and Color Hair: My Honest Experience and Results